Scottish Murders

True Crime Podcasters Roundtable hosts Adam and Paul are joined by guests Dawn and Naomi to explore the intricacies of true crime podcasting. The discussion covers the ethical responsibilities of narrating sensitive cases, the influence of listener feedback, and the delicate balance between humour and respect for victims. The panel also examines the UK prison system, debating early release...

This episode of Scotland Then explores newspaper stories from February 1966, offering a glimpse into Scottish life during that time. Dawn recounts tales from various publications, including the closure of the Deeside Railway, a controversial homicide case, and a dramatic petrol tanker fire in East Kilbride. The episode also highlights technological advancements, such as the first commercial...

This episode focuses on the unsolved 1966 murder of David McMenigall in Edinburgh, exploring the case details, David McMenigall’s lifestyle, the night of his murder, and subsequent police investigations. The episode highlights the focus being on David McMenigall’s personal life in media coverage and discusses the potential murder weapon - a Ford Mustang horse emblem. The episode also touches on...

In this episode listeners are transported back to December 1883, exploring captivating stories from the past. The episode highlights festive preparations with adverts for Christmas sales, a near-disaster at Oban railway station involving gunpowder, and a devastating gale that wreaked havoc across Scotland. Dawn recounts tales of unexpected inheritances, innovative uses of melon seeds, and a...

Trigger warning - This episode covers the topic of suicide. In this episode, we go back to Glasgow in 1883 and explore the tragic murder of 22-year-old Grace Hamilton, a rising theatrical star. The episode looks at the relationship between Grace, whose real name was Janet Russell, and Galbraith Macpherson, a well-connected gentleman from Glasgow. As jealousy and mental instability intertwine, the...

In this episode the focus is on the conclusion of the Liam Fee case. The episode examines the jury's deliberations and the eventual guilty verdicts for Naomi Fee and Rachel Trelfer, who were convicted of the murder of their son, Liam, and the abuse of two other young boys. The narrative explores the aftermath of the trial, including the emotional impact on jurors and the broader community. It...

Listener discretion is strongly advised due to the disturbing content and strong language in this episode.In this episode listeners are taken through the harrowing details of the Liam Fee case, focusing on the remaining weeks of the trial seven week trial. The episode explores the testimonies of various witnesses, including Liam’s former childminder and former nursery staff, who recount their...

Listener discretion is strongly advised due to the disturbing content in this episode.In this intense episode, the host, Dawn, explores the tragic case of two-and-a-half-year-old Liam Fee's murder in 2014, near Glenrothes, Fife. The episode examines the role of jury service in the justice system, highlighting the emotional burden it can impose. Listeners are guided through the distressing details...

In this episode of 'Scotland Then', host Dawn takes listeners on a journey through historical newspaper stories from April 1862. The episode features intriguing tales, including a sensationalised theft in Kilmarnock, a tragic railway accident, and a boating mishap near Dunoon. Dawn also shares lighter moments with humorous anecdotes from the period's newspapers. Throughout the episode, Dawn...

In this episode, host Dawn explores into the chilling case of Mary Timney, a woman convicted of the brutal murder of Ann Hannah in 1862. The episode meticulously unravels the events leading up to Mary Timney's trial, highlighting her persistent claims of innocence despite the circumstantial evidence against her. Dawn explores the dramatic confession that emerged, altering public perception and...